Oklahoma Roofing Institute
Hail-damaged roof shingles after Oklahoma storm

Insurance Claims Reference

Oklahoma Roof Insurance Claims

Know your rights, understand the process, and protect your claim — from first inspection through final settlement.

Oklahoma's Storm Insurance Landscape

Oklahoma consistently ranks among the top states for hail and wind damage claims. With an average of 60+ severe weather days per year, homeowners and contractors alike must understand how the state's insurance framework applies to roofing losses — from initial damage assessment through contractor selection and final payment.

Oklahoma is governed by the Oklahoma Insurance Code (Title 36) and regulated by the Oklahoma Insurance Department (OID). Knowing the applicable statutes, timelines, and documentation requirements is essential to a successful claim.

Insurance claim paperwork and documentation

PROCESS

The Claims Process

Six critical steps from storm event to final settlement — each with specific Oklahoma legal requirements.

01

Document the Damage Immediately

Photograph all damage from multiple angles before any temporary repairs. Date-stamp photos and note the storm event date. Oklahoma courts have upheld claim denials where documentation was insufficient or delayed.

02

File Prompt Written Notice

Oklahoma's unfair claims settlement practices rules (Title 36) require insurers to acknowledge a claim promptly after written notice. File your claim in writing — not just by phone — and retain proof of submission.

03

Request a Certified Inspector

You can hire your own qualified roofing professional or HAAG Certified Inspector to assess the damage independently. Your inspector's findings can be used to support your claim or dispute the insurer's assessment. The carrier is not required to bring a HAAG inspector, but you are not limited to their adjuster's opinion.

04

Share the Scope of Loss with Your Contractor

Once you receive the insurer's written scope of loss (Xactimate or equivalent), provide a copy to your roofing contractor before any work begins. Your contractor must review every line item to confirm the approved scope covers all work necessary to restore the property to pre-storm condition. Common omissions include drip edge replacement, ice & water shield, code-required upgrades, permit fees, and overhead & profit. Any missing items should be identified and submitted as a supplement before repairs start — not after.

05

Understand ACV vs. RCV

Most Oklahoma policies pay Actual Cash Value (ACV) initially, withholding depreciation until repairs are complete. Recover the holdback by submitting a signed contractor invoice showing the full Replacement Cost Value (RCV) work was performed.

06

Dispute Underpayment or Denial

If your claim was underpaid or denied, Oklahoma law provides multiple remedies — from the appraisal process (a standard policy provision under Title 36) for amount disputes to OID complaints and legal action for bad-faith denials. See the full dispute sections below.

Critical Step

Always Share the Scope of Loss with Your Contractor

The insurance scope of loss is the foundation of your repair project. Before signing a contract or allowing work to begin, give your roofing contractor a complete copy. A qualified contractor will compare the approved scope line by line against what is actually required to return your roof and related components to pre-storm condition. If the scope is missing items — or if code-required upgrades were not included — your contractor can identify those gaps and submit a supplement to the insurer before work starts. Waiting until after repairs are complete to discover missing line items puts you at risk of paying out of pocket for work the insurer should have covered.

Claim Denied?

Disputing a Denied Claim

A claim denial is not final. Oklahoma law gives policyholders specific rights to challenge a denial — and insurers who deny without proper cause face significant penalties under state law.

Common Reasons Claims Are Denied

Adjuster attributed damage to "wear and tear" or "pre-existing condition" without adequate inspection
Insurer claims damage does not meet the policy's minimum threshold or deductible
Denial based on roof age alone (may violate HB 2357 if roof is under 15 years old and in reasonable condition)
Insurer alleges late notice of the claim without demonstrating actual prejudice
Damage attributed to a non-covered peril (e.g., "maintenance issue") without a proper investigation
Policy exclusion cited without a written explanation referencing specific policy language
01

Demand the Denial in Writing

Under 36 O.S. § 1250.5, insurers must provide a written denial that cites the specific policy provision, condition, or exclusion relied upon. If you received only a verbal denial or a vague letter, demand a written explanation immediately. This is your legal right.

02

Get an Independent Inspection

Hire a HAAG Certified Inspector or licensed roofing professional to conduct an independent damage assessment. A written, signed inspection report from a credentialed expert directly contradicting the adjuster's findings is the most powerful tool in a denial dispute.

03

Submit a Written Appeal to the Insurer

Write a formal appeal letter to the insurer's claims department — not just your agent. Include your independent inspection report, weather service records confirming the storm event, photos, and a point-by-point rebuttal of the denial rationale. Send via certified mail and retain the receipt.

04

Invoke the Appraisal Clause

If the dispute is over the amount of loss (not coverage), invoke the appraisal process — a standard provision in most Oklahoma homeowner policies under Title 36. Each party selects a competent appraiser; the two appraisers select an umpire. Agreement by any two of the three sets the binding amount of loss. This process bypasses litigation for valuation disputes.

05

File a Complaint with the OID

If the insurer denied your claim without a reasonable investigation, misrepresented your policy, or failed to respond within statutory timeframes, file a complaint with the Oklahoma Insurance Department. The OID can investigate, require the insurer to respond, and impose fines or license sanctions for violations of 36 O.S. § 1250.5.

06

Consult an Insurance Attorney

If the denial appears to be in bad faith — meaning the insurer knew or should have known the claim was valid — you may have grounds for a bad-faith lawsuit under Oklahoma law. Successful bad-faith claims can result in the full policy benefit plus additional damages and attorney fees. Contact the Oklahoma Bar Association Lawyer Referral Service at (405) 416-7000.

Oklahoma Bad-Faith Insurance Law

Oklahoma recognizes both first-party and third-party bad-faith insurance claims. An insurer acts in bad faith when it unreasonably denies, delays, or underpays a valid claim. Under Buzzard v. Farmers Insurance Co. and its progeny, Oklahoma policyholders may recover extracontractual damages — beyond the policy limits — when bad faith is proven. Document every interaction with your insurer carefully; this record becomes critical evidence.

Underpaid?

Disputing an Underpayment

Receiving a partial payment does not mean your claim is closed. Oklahoma law provides clear remedies when the settlement amount does not cover the actual cost of restoring your property to pre-storm condition.

01

Share the Scope with Your Contractor First

Before signing a repair contract, give your contractor the full insurance scope of loss. Your contractor must verify that every line item required to restore the property to pre-storm condition is included — roofing materials, underlayment, drip edge, flashing, ventilation components, and any code-required upgrades. Gaps identified before work begins can be supplemented; gaps discovered after the fact are far harder to recover.

02

Review the Scope of Loss Line by Line

Compare the insurer's Xactimate estimate against your contractor's written estimate. Common omissions include drip edge replacement, ice & water shield, code-required upgrades, permit fees, and overhead & profit for general contractors. Each missing line item is a basis for a supplement.

03

Submit a Supplement

A supplement is a formal request to add missed or undervalued line items to the approved scope. Submit it in writing with supporting documentation — contractor estimates, manufacturer specifications, and code citations where applicable. Insurers are required to respond to supplements within the same statutory timeframes as original claims.

04

Invoke the Appraisal Process

If the insurer refuses to supplement or the parties cannot agree on the amount, invoke the appraisal clause — a standard provision in most Oklahoma homeowner policies. This is the fastest and least expensive path to resolving a valuation dispute without litigation.

05

Recover Withheld Depreciation (RCV Holdback)

If your policy is Replacement Cost Value (RCV), the insurer withholds depreciation until repairs are complete. Once work is finished, submit the signed contractor invoice and request release of the holdback. Oklahoma's prompt-payment rules under Title 36 require the insurer to act within a reasonable time after agreement.

Policyholder Advocate

When to Use a Public Adjuster

A public adjuster is a licensed insurance claims professional who works exclusively for you — the policyholder — not the insurance company. When a claim is complex, disputed, or significantly underpaid, a public adjuster can level the playing field and recover substantially more than a homeowner navigating the process alone.

What a Public Adjuster Does

Public adjusters are hired by policyholders to manage, document, and negotiate insurance claims on their behalf. Unlike the insurance company's adjuster — whose job is to settle the claim for as little as possible — a public adjuster's sole obligation is to maximize your recovery under the terms of your policy.

  • Conducts an independent, line-by-line inspection of all storm damage — including damage the insurer's adjuster missed or undervalued
  • Prepares a complete scope of loss using industry-standard estimating software (Xactimate) to document every repair item
  • Reviews the insurer's estimate and identifies underpayments, missing line items, and improper depreciation
  • Submits and negotiates supplements directly with the insurer's claims department
  • Manages all written communications and deadlines to protect your statutory rights under Title 36 (Oklahoma Insurance Code)
  • Represents you in the appraisal process if the dispute escalates to that policy provision
  • Coordinates with your roofing contractor to ensure the approved scope matches what is actually required to restore the property

When You Should Consider Hiring One

  • Your claim was denied and you believe the denial is unjustified
  • The insurer's settlement offer is significantly lower than your contractor's estimate
  • The damage is extensive — multiple roof sections, structural components, or interior damage from water intrusion
  • You are unfamiliar with Xactimate pricing, insurance policy language, or the supplement process
  • The insurer is slow to respond, unresponsive to supplements, or has missed statutory deadlines
  • You are a commercial property owner with a large or complex loss
  • You have already accepted a partial payment but believe additional amounts are owed

Public Adjuster vs. Insurance Company Adjuster

Public AdjusterInsurance Company Adjuster
Who they work forYou — the policyholderThe insurance company
Primary goalMaximize your recoverySettle the claim efficiently for the insurer
How they are paidContingency fee (% of your settlement)Salary or fee paid by the insurer
License requiredYes — OID public adjuster license (36 O.S. § 6202)Yes — OID staff or independent adjuster license
Scope of loss preparedFull scope on your behalf, including supplementsScope on behalf of the insurer
Appraisal representationCan represent you in the appraisal processRepresents the insurer in appraisal

How Public Adjusters Are Compensated

Public adjusters in Oklahoma are typically paid a contingency fee — a percentage of the final insurance settlement, commonly ranging from 10% to 15% of the recovered amount. They are paid only if they recover money for you. There is no upfront cost. Oklahoma law requires the fee arrangement to be in writing before any work begins. Be cautious of any public adjuster who requests payment before a settlement is reached or who charges a flat fee regardless of outcome.

Oklahoma Licensing Requirements

Public adjusters in Oklahoma must be licensed by the Oklahoma Insurance Department under 36 O.S. § 6202. Before hiring, verify the adjuster's license is active and in good standing. An unlicensed person representing themselves as a public adjuster is committing a crime under Oklahoma law.

Verify Public Adjuster License at OID

Caution: Know Who You Are Dealing With

After a major storm, unlicensed individuals sometimes pose as public adjusters or offer to "handle your claim" as part of a roofing sales pitch. This is illegal in Oklahoma. A legitimate public adjuster will provide their OID license number on request, present a written fee agreement before doing any work, and never ask you to sign over your insurance benefits (an Assignment of Benefits, or AOB, is not permitted in Oklahoma for residential property claims). If someone pressures you to sign documents immediately after a storm, verify their license before proceeding.

Oklahoma Insurance Department

File a Complaint with the Oklahoma Insurance Commissioner

The Oklahoma Insurance Commissioner, operating through the Oklahoma Insurance Department (OID), has statutory authority to investigate insurer misconduct, impose fines, suspend or revoke licenses, and compel corrective action. Filing a formal complaint is free, does not require an attorney, and creates an official record of the insurer's conduct.

When to File with the OID

Claim denied or underpaid without a written explanation citing specific policy language (36 O.S. § 1250.5)
Insurer failed to acknowledge your claim promptly after written notice (Title 36, unfair claims settlement practices)
Claim not accepted or denied within 45 days of receiving proof of loss
Payment not issued within 5 business days of written agreement on the amount
Adjuster misrepresented your policy terms, coverage, or your legal rights
Insurer refused to conduct a reasonable investigation before denying the claim
Policy cancelled or non-renewed in retaliation for filing a legitimate storm damage claim
Insurer applied a roof age exclusion to a roof under 15 years old in reasonable condition (HB 2357)
01

Attempt Direct Resolution First

Contact the insurer's claims supervisor in writing and document the outcome. The OID will ask whether you attempted to resolve the issue directly before filing. Keep a record of the date, representative name, and response.

02

Assemble Your File

Gather your policy declarations page, all written correspondence with the insurer, the denial or underpayment letter, the scope of loss, your contractor's estimate, photos of damage, and weather service records. A complete file accelerates the OID's review.

03

File Online at oid.ok.gov

Visit oid.ok.gov and select "File a Complaint." Complete Consumer Complaint Form OID-CP-1 with your policy number, insurer name, claim number, and a clear description of the violation. Upload supporting documents directly through the portal.

04

File by Mail or Fax

Mail Form OID-CP-1 to: Oklahoma Insurance Department, Consumer Assistance Division, P.O. Box 53408, Oklahoma City, OK 73152-3408. Fax: (405) 521-6635. Send by certified mail and retain the receipt.

05

What the OID Does Next

The OID forwards your complaint to the insurer and requires a written response, typically within 20 days. The OID reviews the response against Oklahoma law and your policy. If a violation is confirmed, the OID may impose fines, require corrective payment, or initiate license disciplinary proceedings against the insurer.

OID Contact Information

Address

Oklahoma Insurance Department 313 NE 21st Street Oklahoma City, OK 73105

Phone

(800) 522-0071 (toll-free) / (405) 521-2828

Hours

Monday–Friday, 8:00 AM–4:30 PM CST

File a Complaint Online

What the OID Cannot Do

The OID regulates insurer conduct — it cannot act as your attorney, force a specific settlement amount, or represent you in litigation. If you need legal representation, contact the Oklahoma Bar Association Lawyer Referral Service at (405) 416-7000 or consult a licensed Oklahoma insurance attorney.

Oklahoma Attorney General

File a Complaint with the Oklahoma Attorney General

When insurance misconduct or contractor conduct crosses from a civil dispute into criminal fraud, the Oklahoma Attorney General's Office has authority to investigate and prosecute. The AG's Consumer Protection Unit enforces the Oklahoma Consumer Protection Act (15 O.S. § 751 et seq.) and coordinates with the OID and law enforcement on insurance fraud cases.

Insurance Fraud — What It Looks Like

Insurance fraud in the roofing context is a crime under 36 O.S. § 1435.1 et seq. It can be committed by insurers, adjusters, or contractors. Knowing the warning signs protects you from both being a victim and being unknowingly implicated.

  • Insurer or adjuster knowingly misrepresents policy terms or coverage to avoid paying a valid claim
  • Adjuster falsifies inspection findings or damage reports to support a denial
  • Contractor inflates or fabricates damage on an insurance estimate to collect more than the actual loss
  • Contractor offers to waive, absorb, or "cover" your deductible — this is illegal under Oklahoma law and constitutes insurance fraud by both parties
  • Contractor collects insurance proceeds and fails to complete the agreed scope of work (contractor fraud / theft by deception)
  • Storm-chaser contractor uses high-pressure tactics, forged credentials, or false FORTIFIED/HAAG certifications to solicit work after a disaster
  • Insurer systematically underpays claims across multiple policyholders using manipulated Xactimate pricing profiles

Contractor Fraud — Your Rights

Oklahoma law provides specific protections against roofing contractor fraud. Under 15 O.S. § 765.1, a homeowner who signs a contract with an unregistered contractor or a contractor who misrepresents their credentials may void the contract. Oklahoma's storm-chaser law requires out-of-state contractors who solicit work following a disaster to register with the CIB within 10 days of beginning work — failure to do so is subject to civil penalties of up to $10,000 per occurrence.

  • Contractor abandons the job after receiving the insurance check (theft by deception — 21 O.S. § 1541)
  • Contractor performs substandard work that does not match the agreed scope or approved insurance estimate
  • Contractor misrepresents FORTIFIED, HAAG, or other certifications to win the job
  • Contractor uses unlicensed subcontractors without disclosure, voiding manufacturer warranties
  • Contractor refuses to provide lien waivers after payment, exposing the homeowner to mechanic's liens
  • Contractor solicits door-to-door after a declared disaster without required CIB registration (Oklahoma storm-chaser law)

How to File an AG Complaint

01

Determine the Right Agency

The AG's Consumer Protection Unit handles deceptive trade practices and fraud. For insurance-specific violations, file with both the OID and the AG simultaneously — they coordinate on cases involving licensed insurers or adjusters. For contractor fraud involving criminal theft, also file a police report with your local law enforcement agency.

02

Document Everything Before Filing

Gather your signed contract, all receipts and payment records, the insurance scope of loss, photos of the work performed (or not performed), written communications with the contractor or insurer, and any witnesses. The AG's office needs a clear paper trail to pursue action.

03

File Online at oag.ok.gov

Visit oag.ok.gov and navigate to the Consumer Protection section to submit a complaint online. Describe the conduct in detail, identify the business by name and address, and attach all supporting documentation. The AG's office will review and determine whether to investigate or refer the matter.

04

File by Mail

Mail your complaint to: Oklahoma Attorney General's Office, Consumer Protection Unit, 313 NE 21st Street, Oklahoma City, OK 73105. Include copies (not originals) of all supporting documents. Send by certified mail and retain the receipt.

05

Report Insurance Fraud to the OID Fraud Unit

The OID maintains a dedicated Insurance Fraud Unit that investigates criminal insurance fraud separately from consumer complaints. Report suspected fraud — by an insurer, adjuster, or contractor — to the OID Fraud Unit at (405) 521-6600 or via the fraud reporting form at oid.ok.gov. The Fraud Unit coordinates with the AG and district attorneys for prosecution.

Penalties Under Oklahoma Law

36 O.S. § 1435.1Insurance fraud — felony, up to 10 years imprisonment and fines up to $10,000 per act
21 O.S. § 1541Theft by deception (contractor abandonment) — felony if amount exceeds $1,000
15 O.S. § 761.1Oklahoma Consumer Protection Act violations — civil penalties up to $10,000 per violation plus restitution
Storm-Chaser LawUnregistered storm-chaser contractor — civil penalties up to $10,000 per occurrence
OAC 365:15-3-1Deductible waiver by contractor — insurance fraud, policy voidance, and contractor license revocation

Attorney General Contact Information

Address

Oklahoma Attorney General's Office 313 NE 21st Street Oklahoma City, OK 73105

Phone

(405) 521-3921

OID Insurance Fraud Unit: (405) 521-6600

Website

oag.ok.gov

Key Oklahoma Statutes & Regulations

59 O.S. § 1151.30

Deductible Waiver Prohibition

Prohibits roofing contractors from waiving, absorbing, or rebating a homeowner's insurance deductible as an inducement to enter a contract. Violations subject the contractor to CIB disciplinary action and potential criminal liability.

36 O.S. § 1250.6

Prompt Payment of Claims

Requires insurers to acknowledge claims promptly, accept or deny within 45 days of receiving proof of loss, and pay accepted claims promptly after agreement. Violations may result in interest penalties and attorney fees under Oklahoma's Insurance Code.

Policy Appraisal Clause

Appraisal Provision

Most Oklahoma homeowner policies include an appraisal clause under Title 36 of the Insurance Code. Either party may invoke it when there is a disagreement on the amount of loss. Each party appoints a competent appraiser; the two appraisers select an umpire. Agreement by any two of the three sets the amount of loss.

36 O.S. § 1250.5

Unfair Claims Settlement Practices

Prohibits insurers from misrepresenting policy provisions, failing to acknowledge communications promptly, refusing to pay claims without reasonable investigation, or compelling insureds to litigate by offering substantially less than due.

OAC 365:15-3-1

Contractor Solicitation Rules

Oklahoma prohibits contractors from waiving, absorbing, or rebating an insured's deductible. Contractors who offer to cover deductibles as a business practice are in violation of state law and may expose the homeowner to policy cancellation.

36 O.S. § 4669

Residential Roofing Contractor Registration

Roofing contractors performing residential work in Oklahoma must be registered with the Oklahoma Construction Industries Board (CIB). Verify registration before signing any contract — unregistered contractors void certain warranty protections.

HB 2357 (2022)

Roof Age & Material Restrictions

Oklahoma law limits insurers from denying coverage or non-renewing a policy solely based on roof age if the roof is less than 15 years old and in reasonable condition. Insurers must provide written notice and inspection opportunity before any adverse action.

Documentation Checklist

A well-documented claim is a protected claim. Gather and preserve the following before, during, and after the claims process.

Before the Adjuster Visit

  • Date-stamped photos of all damage (roof, gutters, siding, skylights)
  • Weather service records confirming storm event date and hail size
  • Prior inspection reports or maintenance records
  • Written claim notice submitted to insurer with delivery confirmation

During the Inspection

  • Request a copy of the adjuster's field notes and measurements
  • Have your own contractor or HAAG inspector present
  • Note any damage the adjuster does not include in the scope
  • Photograph the adjuster's inspection process

After Settlement

  • Provide the full scope of loss to your contractor before work begins
  • Signed contractor invoice showing full RCV scope completed
  • Permit and final inspection records from local jurisdiction
  • Manufacturer's warranty registration for new materials
  • Contractor's certificate of insurance and CIB registration number
Oklahoma Insurance Department

How to File a Complaint with the OID

If your insurer or adjuster has acted unfairly, delayed your claim, underpaid, or denied without proper cause, the Oklahoma Insurance Department (OID) has authority to investigate and take action.

When You Should File a Complaint

Your insurer failed to acknowledge your claim promptly after written notice
Your claim was denied or underpaid without a written explanation citing specific policy language
The insurer failed to accept or deny your claim within 45 days of receiving proof of loss
Payment was not issued within 5 business days after you reached written agreement on the amount
Your adjuster misrepresented your policy terms or coverage provisions
The insurer refused to conduct a reasonable investigation before denying your claim
You were threatened with policy cancellation for filing a legitimate storm damage claim
An independent adjuster acted outside the scope of their license or misrepresented their authority

How to File — Step by Step

1

Try to Resolve Directly First

Before filing with the OID, contact your insurer's claims supervisor or customer service department in writing. Document the date, name of the representative, and outcome. The OID may ask whether you attempted direct resolution.

2

Gather Your Documentation

Collect your policy declarations page, all written correspondence with the insurer, the denial or underpayment letter, your scope of loss, photos of damage, contractor estimates, and any weather service records. The stronger your file, the faster the OID can act.

3

Submit Online at oid.ok.gov

Visit oid.ok.gov and select "File a Complaint." Complete the Consumer Complaint Form (Form OID-CP-1). You will need your policy number, insurer name, claim number, and a clear description of the issue. Attach supporting documents.

4

Submit by Mail or Fax

Mail completed Form OID-CP-1 to: Oklahoma Insurance Department, Consumer Assistance Division, P.O. Box 53408, Oklahoma City, OK 73152-3408. Fax: (405) 521-6635. Keep a copy of everything you submit.

5

Call the OID Consumer Hotline

For questions before filing or to check complaint status, call (800) 522-0071 (toll-free in Oklahoma) or (405) 521-2828. Hours: Monday–Friday, 8:00 AM–4:30 PM CST.

6

What Happens After You File

The OID will send your complaint to the insurer and require a written response, typically within 20 days. The OID reviews the response against Oklahoma law and your policy. If a violation is found, the OID may impose fines, require payment, or take disciplinary action against the insurer's license.

Complaints Against Adjusters

Independent and public adjusters in Oklahoma must be licensed by the OID under 36 O.S. § 6202. If an adjuster misrepresented damage, acted outside their license, or engaged in deceptive practices, file a separate complaint with the OID's Licensing Division. Include the adjuster's full name, license number (if known), employer, and a detailed account of the conduct.

Verify Adjuster License

What the OID Cannot Do

The OID regulates insurer conduct — it cannot act as your attorney, force a specific settlement amount, or represent you in litigation. If you believe you need legal representation, consult an Oklahoma-licensed insurance attorney or contact the Oklahoma Bar Association's Lawyer Referral Service at (405) 416-7000.

OID Contact Information

Mailing Address

Oklahoma Insurance Department 313 NE 21st Street Oklahoma City, OK 73105

Phone

(800) 522-0071 (toll-free) / (405) 521-2828

Hours

Monday–Friday, 8:00 AM–4:30 PM CST

Website

oid.ok.gov

Oklahoma Resources

Oklahoma Insurance Department (OID)

File complaints, verify insurer licenses, and access consumer guides at oid.ok.gov.

Visit Resource

Oklahoma Construction Industries Board (CIB)

Verify roofing contractor registration and file complaints against unlicensed contractors.

Visit Resource

IBHS FORTIFIED Program

Upgrading to FORTIFIED standards during a re-roof can qualify for insurance discounts and stronger coverage terms.

Visit Resource

National Weather Service — Norman, OK

Access official storm event records, hail size reports, and severe weather history for insurance documentation.

Visit Resource

Get a HAAG-Certified Roof Inspection

Before you file — or if your claim was denied or underpaid — a HAAG Certified Inspector can provide an independent, court-recognized assessment of your roof damage.

Storm-damaged roof requiring insurance claim